Page 1 of 1
Getting odd error in SSH server OnClientError event
Posted: Thu 04 Jan 2018 20:45
by snorkel
I have been getting this odd error in the OnClientError in the SSH server:
SSH Client(0.0.0.0:519) ERROR for user:N/A:Authentication failed
The last part after the : is the error from the server the other stuff I pull from the ClientInfo: TScSSHClientInfo passed to the event.
the ClientInfo object has a port and a 0.0.0.0 IP address which is odd as that's the listening IP address i.e. listen on all interfaces.
Anyone have any idea on how to figure out what is causing this? Right around this time we do get 3 valid connections from a particular user account.
Re: Getting odd error in SSH server OnClientError event
Posted: Fri 05 Jan 2018 15:35
by ViktorV
Unfortunately, we could not reproduce this case when client IP equals 0.0.0.0 in the OnClientError event handler. TClientInfo.SockAddr specifies the IP and port of the client. To get the IP and port of the client in the OnClientError event handler, you can use the following code:
Code: Select all
procedure TSSHServerFrame.ScSSHServerClientError(Sender: TObject;
ClientInfo: TScSSHClientInfo; E: Exception);
var
IP: string;
Port: integer;
begin
IP := string(inet_ntoa(ClientInfo.SockAddr.sin_addr));
Port := ClientInfo.SockAddr.sin_port;
end;
Re: Getting odd error in SSH server OnClientError event
Posted: Mon 08 Jan 2018 16:21
by snorkel
That's almost exactly how I get the IP in Lazarus:
if ClientInfo <> nil then
begin
ip:=inet_ntoa(clientinfo.SockAddr^.sin_addr);
port:=intTostr(ntohs(ClientInfo.SockAddr^.sin_port));
I'm having a problem figuring out what the heck is causing this error.
The client info object is not null, but it does not have a username and it never hits the password or the key auth events in the tscFilestorage, yet the error that is raised is Auth Failure.
This is on a real server not a desktop and we transfer a ton of files and this error happens every day around the same time.
Re: Getting odd error in SSH server OnClientError event
Posted: Mon 08 Jan 2018 16:38
by snorkel
I noticed that each day it's always on the same ports:
On Jan 5th:
SSH Client(0.0.0.0:65287) ERROR for user:N/A:Authentication failed
SSH Client(0.0.0.0:519) ERROR for user:N/A:Authentication failed
On Jan 4th:
SSH Client(0.0.0.0:65287) ERROR for user:N/A:Authentication failed
SSH Client(0.0.0.0:519) ERROR for user:N/A:Authentication failed
Is this possible some type of listener error and not really a Authentication failed error.
I am using a slightly older version of Securebridge, it's not the latest.
Re: Getting odd error in SSH server OnClientError event
Posted: Thu 11 Jan 2018 13:54
by ViktorV
We will add the BeforeClientConnect event handler, in which you can save ClientInfo and then compare the saved information with ClientInfo in the OnClientError event handler. We'll let you know when we add the above event handler.
Re: Getting odd error in SSH server OnClientError event
Posted: Wed 03 Oct 2018 13:23
by tcaduto12068
I think we may have found the source of this error:
SSH Client(0.0.0.0:65287) ERROR for user:N/A:Authentication failed
SSH Client(0.0.0.0:519) ERROR for user:N/A:Authentication failed
It appears the devart SSH/SFTP server is dropping the connections because of the backlog limit or possibly the max startups.
I have the backlog set to 15 and the max startups set to 150 and one of our clients sent 11 files in separate sessions at one time. I have since increased the backlog to 50 and left max startups at 150.
If this is indeed the cause of the above error is there anyway you guys can add better error handling for when this happens?
Maybe an event or something that is triggered?
Re: Getting odd error in SSH server OnClientError event
Posted: Thu 04 Oct 2018 17:34
by tcaduto12068
I think I tracked this error down to this function:
Line 120 in procedure TSsh2ServerConnection.UserAuthentication;
I am guessing this is where it does some server key verification?
Their connections work sometimes and other times we get this:
SSH Client(0.0.0.0:56838) ERROR for user:N/A:Authentication failed
Is there anyway to get the actual error that caused the Auth to fail?
Re: Getting odd error in SSH server OnClientError event
Posted: Fri 05 Oct 2018 15:16
by ViktorV
We are investigating the issue and will notify you about the result.
Re: Getting odd error in SSH server OnClientError event
Posted: Tue 08 Jan 2019 14:29
by ViktorV
Please check whether the specified behavior is reproduced when using the latest version of SecureBridge 9.0.1